Law could adversely affect fishing vessel response program

In 2023, a Federal law was passed that could affect Alyeska’s contracted fleet of fishing vessels trained to help respond in case of an oil spill in Prince William Sound.

Fishing fleet available for a quick response

When the Exxon Valdez oil spill happened, the response was delayed. Much of the damage could have been lessened if clean-up efforts had started immediately. One of the most important lessons of that spill was that local fishing crews can help with a quick response.

The local fishing crews who joined the 1989 response realized that pulling oil spill boom was similar to pulling a net of fish. They also knew the region’s waters well, and were aware of dangers like shallow areas or changing tides that could leave a vessel stranded, among other hazards.

In the years since the spill, Alyeska formalized this relationship, developing a program to make sure they have a contracted fleet of vessels that are trained, on-call, and immediately available to support a response in case of another spill. Today, Alyeska holds contracts with more than 350 of these vessels. They invest in training for crew members every year to make sure they are always ready to respond.

Alyeska trains the crews to handle oil spill response equipment, tow oil spill boom in proper formation, and tow the small barges used to store the oil and water mix that is recovered during a spill response. They are skilled in deploying, operating, and maintaining this equipment.

A small vessel pulls a bright yellow boom into formation during an exercise. The Valdez Marine Terminal is on shore in the background.
Alyeska responders practice maneuvers in front of the Valdez Marine Terminal. Photo by Nelli Vanderburg.

Consequences for the contracted fishing vessel program

If a real event were to occur, Alaska’s fishing crews would be ready to respond.

However, a section of the National Defense Authorization Act of 2023 that was intended to exempt fishing vessels from the inspection requirements when working an oil spill was interpreted by Coast Guard to require the vessels to undergo inspections.

These vessels are uninspected and were designed and built specifically for fishing, not oil spill response. These vessels have not been subject to Coast Guard inspection before and many would not be able to meet inspection requirements, meaning they would be excluded from participating in a response.

“Trying to replace uninspected fishing vessels with vessels that meet Coast Guard inspection requirements would completely dismantle the program that has been part of the response system in Prince William Sound for decades,” said Donna Schantz, executive director for the Council. “This would greatly diminish oil spill response capabilities in our region, as well as the entire nation. The trained fleet, made up of contracted local fisherman who understand the waters, are the backbone of the response system and are essential to help mitigate impacts to people, communities, economies, and the environment.”

Workgroup partnership looking for a solution

The Council has been participating in a workgroup to help develop a solution that would allow the current fleet to remain in operation. Members include the Council, Cook Inlet Regional Citizens Advisory Council, Alyeska/SERVS, and other industry and oil spill removal organizations across the country.

New staff member joins Anchorage office

Suparat Prasannet
Suparat Prasannet

In December, the Council welcomed a new staff member, Suparat Prasannet. Prasannet has a background in office management, previously overseeing operations at Alaska Immigration Law Center, where she streamlined systems and kept everything running smoothly. Alongside her administrative expertise, Prasannet is pursuing a degree in marketing.

Her duties as the IT/Admin Assistant for the Council include maintaining and managing hardware, software, online services, network infrastructure, and oversight of the Council’s historical digital archive, among other duties. She replaces Hans Odegard, who was promoted to Director of Administration last year.

Community Corner: Watch parties expand reach of annual science event

A responder stands behind the railing on the deck of a small boat holding a long thin pole. A whale is about 10 feet from the side of the boat. The responder is reaching into the water with the pole towards the whale to help remove the debris tangled around the whale.
A responder works to rescue a tangled humpback whale in Port Valdez in 2024. During Science Night, John Moran from the Alaska Fisheries Science Center told the story of the rescue and explained how their team is trained to do this work safely. This rescue was permitted under NOAA #24359. Photo courtesy of Alaska Fisheries Science Center.

Each year in early December, the Council hosts our annual Science Night. We invite experts to share about their scientific work and programs that are relevant to the Exxon Valdez oil spill region.

In 2024, the Council partnered with several local organizations to host community watch parties for the first time. We are grateful to our host partners: the Prince William Sound Science Center in Cordova, Kenai Peninsula College in Homer, and Prince William Sound College in Valdez. Each organization invited community members to gather in their facilities to watch the broadcast from Anchorage.

Science Night 2024: Staying alert and proactive in the Exxon Valdez oil spill region

This event highlighted four programs.

  • John Moran, a Research Fisheries Biologist from the Alaska Fisheries Science Center shared about how he and his team of trained responders freed an entangled humpback whale in Valdez in 2024.
  • Kristina Arsenault, a Marine Transportation System Specialist (Cyber) from the U.S. Coast Guard’s Marine Safety Unit in Valdez spoke on marine cybersecurity.
  • Andy Schroeder and Scott Farling, Co-Founders of Ocean Plastics Recovery Project, shared about their marine debris cleanup and recycling efforts focused on the Southcentral Alaska coast.
  • Finally, Barbara Callahan, Senior Director of Response and Preparedness Services at the International Bird Rescue presented about innovations in oiled wildlife response since the Exxon Valdez spill.

Dr. Sarah Allan, chair of the Council’s Scientific Advisory Committee, attended the watch party in Homer. She had attended broadcasts in previous years as an individual attendee, and shared that it was “more engaging to watch with a group and we had some good side conversations about the presentations.”

Watch Science Night 2024 online

All four presentations are available to view on the Council’s website: Science Night 2024

Join us for Science Night 2025

For Science Night 2025, we hope to build on these successful watch parties by enhancing the opportunities for communities to gather and experience the event together based on feedback we received. We also hope to expand to other communities within the Council’s region. If you have interest in hosting a watch party for your community, please contact me at maia.draper-reich@pwsrcac.org.

Traces of metals found in Prince William Sound’s sediments

Further study needed to determine source and potential effects

Three people stand in front of equipment used to collect sediment from the bottom of the sea floor.
Dr. Bender (left) and staff members Danielle Verna (middle) and Jeremy Robida (right) collected the samples last summer. Dr. Bender later tested the samples in a lab for the presence of a variety of metals.

A new Council study has confirmed that sediments in Port Valdez contain traces of metals at concentrations that could negatively affect the organisms that live at the sea floor.

This pilot study was conducted in 2024, during the routine environmental monitoring conducted by the Council since 1993. The work was prompted by a previous analysis that showed the presence of metals in the water discharged from the Valdez Marine Terminal’s ballast water treatment facility.

Council staff and Dr. Morgan Bender from Fjord & Fish Sciences collected samples of sediments from two locations in Port Valdez: one near the terminal, and a reference site near Gold Creek. The site near the terminal was chosen to confirm whether the metals found in the previous study were accumulating in nearby sediments. Gold Creek was sampled for comparison.

Dr. Bender compared the results to sediment quality guidelines developed by the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, or NOAA. These guidelines are used to determine whether toxins in sediment are concentrated enough to harm organisms.

Both sites show increased concentrations of metals

A gloved hand holds a jar of grey sediment collected during sampling.
Sediment sample.

The study found a total of 22 metals between the two sites, in varying concentrations.

 

Both sites exceeded NOAA’s sediment quality guidelines for eight of the metals: iron, vanadium, aluminum, arsenic, nickel, cobalt, copper, and selenium.

“Terminal sediments had significantly higher metal concentrations overall,” when compared to Gold Creek, states the report, including four metals that were previously found in water discharges from the treatment facility: iron, aluminum, copper, and vanadium. However, all these metals also exceeded the threshold for effect at Gold Creek.

The report noted that “there is a potential ecological risk” from the discharge of these metals.

Local conditions may contribute to high metal concentrations

“Port Valdez is a metal-rich system with a history of copper and gold mining and several large, glacially-fed rivers entering within miles of the sampling locations,” Dr. Bender noted in the report. “These local sources may explain regional patterns such as high iron concentration.”

Dr. Bender noted that while some metals could be tied to the discharge from the terminal, further study is needed to determine the actual source of the metals.


Why are metals of concern?
Metals such as those found in this study are generally stable and do not degrade. Accumulated metals at toxic levels can have a variety of adverse effects, including organ damage, cancer, and damage to DNA. They can enter the food chain when ingested by the tiny organisms that live in the sediment.


Read the report: 2024 Sediment Metals Report

The study was prompted by a previous analysis investigating traces of hydrocarbons and metals in the effluent from the Valdez Marine Terminal’s ballast water treatment facility. Metals were present in that analysis: Examining the Effectiveness of Ballast Water Treatment Processes

Skip to content